Taslima Nasreen decides to escape from India - Instablogs
Taslima Nasreen decides to escape from India
Rezwan , Dhaka: Mar 19 2008
Made Popular Mar 19 2008
Bangladesh :

Taslima Nasreen decides to escape from IndiaTaslima Nasreen, the controversial Bangladeshi author living in exile in India has had enough in that country. She was first driven out of Kolkata in September 2007 because of a movement by Islamic extremists and communist sympathizers demanding expulsion of Taslima from India. The Intelligence Bureau kept her in a ’safe house’ within a National Security Guards complex in Delhi.

But this recluse had taken toll on her. India’s External Affairs Minister Pranab Mukherjee assured Nasreen a “shelter” in India on conditions and Taslima apparently had to agree to a compromise formula. On November 30, 2007 Taslima agreed to remove three pages from her book Dwikhondito (Split up into two). The book has been criticized by Muslims as “anti-Islamic”. (BBC and wikipedia)

On 20 January 2008 she wrote a poem which was published in The Statesman of Calcutta:

Was a poet ever kept in house arrest?
May be she has been a subject of politicking
True she caused clashes once in a while
May be an arson, too.
But no, a poet was never taken to safe custody.
This India, this civilization, this 21st century
They all had welcomed the poet
Ignoring its childish religionism, its merciless politics.
But today, the poet languishes in house arrest.
She has done no offense.

On 11 March 2008, Taslima Nasreen wrote in Mukto-mona, an internet activism group:

Where am I? I am certain no one will believe me if I say I have no answer to this apparently straightforward question, but the truth is I just do not know.

What crime have I committed that I have to spend my life hidden away, relegated to the shadows? For what crimes am I being punished by this society, this land? I wrote of my beliefs and my convictions. I used words, not violence, to express my ideas. I did not take recourse to pelting stones or bloodshed to make my point. Yet, I am considered a criminal. I am being persecuted because it was felt that the right of others to express their opinions was more legitimate than mine.

I know I have not been condemned by the masses. If their opinion had been sought, I am certain the majority would have wanted me to stay on in Bengal. But when has a democracy reflected the voice of the masses? A democracy is run by those who hold the reins of power, who do exactly what they think fit.

And finally she decides to quit India. In an email to IANS she writes:

I used to call this the torture chamber. I gradually came to realise that it was the chamber of death instead. I was not even allowed to stay in hospital for long though the doctors felt it was necessary in order to stabilise my blood pressure.

Even though they constantly pressured me mentally to leave the country, I refused to budge. I was determined I would not leave this country. When they saw it was pointless trying to destroy my mind, they attempted to destroy my body. In this they succeeded by ruining my health, which leaves me with no other alternative but to leave this country.

(Image courtesy: Wikipedia)

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
2 Stars
It’s pathetic to see our leaders treat a writer like that. All our leaders have done is to shame the tolerant Indian public by acting on vested communal grounds and here is the country which always embraces and welcomes everybody into it’s great land, which has now been forced to send Taslima Nasreen out.Whatever happened to Freedom of thought and expression?
1 Stars
Lalit
Kanpur, India
Its Indian 'Lajja' (shame)and Taslima's decision to go out of India is the example of victory of pseudo-secular forces in India. Parties like UNPA or third front or whatever are champion of Muslim vote bank politics and the UPA government is not in favour of sending wrong signals to Muslims in India because the next General election is scheduled next year.
1 Stars
Swati
Amritsar, India
Taslima cannot survive without living in Benagli culture. Its India's shame the government couldn't grant security to a brilliant writer. Where is Gujarat CM Narendra Modi who had announced to give her a shelter?
2 Stars
Fahim
Dhaka, Bangladesh
Indian government gave her what she deserved. Taslima should better come back to Bangladesh, her own country, and apologize to her own people for writing against them and the religion. She should accept punishment in her own country.
2 Stars
Fahim
Dhaka, Bangladesh
This is just another example of the hypocritical attitude of Indian leaders. I was wondering when the Indian leaders were creating uproar for Taslima Nasreen some two months back. Finally, they forced her to go out of India because its election time now. I had written a post on it on Instablogs - Taslima should come back and accept punishment and received great response.
1 Stars
MOhammad
Dhaka, Bangladesh
According to me, we should listen what her problems are with Islam and Muslims of Bangladesh. She should have the right to express herself without hesitation and we should listen what exactly she wants.
1 Stars
Meherun
Dhaka, Bangladesh
Taslima is facing it all wrong. She doesn't deserve to be treated like this not in Bangladesh and not even in India. We had a thought that India is the country of intellectuals but no, fundamentals are also enjoying great power in that country too.
1 Stars
Nitesh
Chennai, India
UPA government has proved once again that it is in search of Muslim votes in next general election. Indian political parties are champion of practicing policy of appeasement to Minorities. This is one more example of that.
1 Stars
Hiten
Ranchi, India
look what Taslima has said on her departure from India - 'She is being forced to go abroad to get urgent medical help as she has been under enormous mental and physical stress in solitary confinement in a safe house in Delhi.'
1 Stars
Sweta
Gwalior, India
Taslima is going through a bad phase in her life. In the month of March 2007, one Islamic group (All India Ittehad Millat Council) had announced to give Rs 5,00,000 for her beheading. In the month of August, MIM activists attacked her at the Hyderabad Press Club when she was to launch her novel Shodh in Telegu. violence broke out in Kolkata against her residence in the city. She was moved to Jaipur and New Delhi and finally she has decided to go out of India.
1 Stars
Hemant
Varanasi, India
MF Hussein should get exactly what Taslima got in India. Taslima dishonored her own religion and MF Hussein bring disrespect to Hindu Goddesses through his 'bakwas' paintings. India don't need such artists and writers.
2 Stars
Prabhunarayan
Pondicherry, India
None has the right to hurt religious sentiments of Muslim, Hindu, Christian, Jews or others. Its better to turn your head and leave than criticing any religion. Taslima is making her life harder and she would face the same in any country.
0 Stars
Ankita
Thane, India
Fundamentalists have won and secular India lost the battle. Taslima has decided to leave India for Europe. Who says India is secular? UPA government should keep quite and avoid commenting on her departure. We couldn't provide her a safe place in the country. Its a shame..
1 Stars
Sumit
Agra, India
Her statement is saying it all. she told a newspaper - "I have always considered India my home and had come here from abroad after 12 years. The Indian government are now turning me out. I can't live here like this anymore". Congratulations to Manmohan Singh.
1 Stars
Salma
Dhaka, Bangladesh
India claim on every possible occasion that It is surrounded by failed states. For India, Bangladesh is too a failed state. Now, Taslima's decision to leave India shows real side of coin and claims that India's pretensions to occupy the moral high ground in the South-Asian region is a joke because India has 'secular ' leaders like Pranab Mukherjee, PR Dasmunshi and Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee living in Bengal. they have made India more a failed concept than the failed states surrounding India.
1 Stars
Eko
Jakarta, Indonesia
I wonder why do Indians express their love for Taslima ? I guess it happens because she writes against Muslims and Islam. How can secular India support a writer who writes against Islam. Talsmia should better become Hindu or Christian. But I want to ask question to all Hindus - "Would you people continue your support to her if she starts writing against Hinduism?" You will start abusing in the same tone than..
1 Stars
Giorgio
Liverpool, United Kingdom
Whatever you can say it - Shame India or Blame India - Taslima issue is a matter of shame for Indian politicians and a black spot on India's secular image. Its an example of rise of Islamic fundamentalism under the umbrella of pseudo-secular parties in the country.
1 Stars
Johan
Jakarta, Indonesia
India has a history of granting shelter to person who is seeking it but now the tradition has been broken by the government itself. Indians should ashamed because they have shown no courage to save a brilliant writer from religious fundamentals.
1 Stars
Sukhbahar
Ludhiana, India
For voters in India - it's a message to you - Taslima is being forced to escape from India that is being ruled by the 'claimed' most secular political alliance. earlier she was forced to leave the state ruled by champions of secularism - the Communists. Now, it's up to voters to decide what they want in next Lok Sabha?
1 Stars
Shweta
Shimla, India
Its shameful nothing else..Millions of Bengali intellectuals and seculars finally taught a Bengali writer lesson and told her that after all they have to contest elections and they don't want to lose the Muslim vote bank. This was the example of great Bengali culture and hospitality and the whole world saw it.
1 Stars
Vinit
Mangalore, India
For me, It more a shame for Bengal than India because Bengal refused to give shelter to a Bengali writer. Gujarat had offered her a secure place to live but Taslima loved Kolkata and she wanted to live in Bengal. It is party time for Bengali leaders and intellectuals for showing cowardice behaviour. History won't forgive you.
1 Stars
Shweta
Shimla, India
I need statements of intellectual Indian who happen to be celebrities too like Shabana Azami, Javed Akhtar, Teesta Seetalvad, Amir Khan and last but not the least Rajdeep Sardesai. can you people write something on it and mind you the super lady is watching you.
1 Stars
Ekta
Jaipur, India
As an ashamed India, all I can say that we are sorry to watching you leaving India. We just love you writings and we will be waiting for your return to Kolkata soon. Politicians are forcing you to leave but our affection would force you to come India once again.
1 Stars
Mayuri Majumdar
Kolkata, India
It is alarming that Indian government couldn’t provide her shelter. Whenever she wins an award or something, she is linked to India and whenever there is an upsurge, she becomes a refugee from Bangladesh. I fail to understand politics but what about human emotions? Literature is a form of art which strives in freedom of expression and that is what she did. If people do not understand that, that is not her problem or mistake.
1 Stars
Reshmi
Bangalore, India
The blame game is in its full swing...some people are blaming the Government, some the hypocrisy of Indian people..but what amuses me is that Bengalis are driven into this controversy by saying that it’s a matter of shame for them for not providing shelter to Taslima in Kolkata...how can the Bengalis be blamed for what has been an entirely political decision? As far as my knowledge goes, most of the intellectuals, celebrities, literateurs, and the common men have protested vociferously against Taslima being ousted from the city which she apparently loves the most, i.e. Kolkata. But the way violent protests erupted in Kolkata and the city was completely thrown off gear when unruly mobs protested against Taslima’s controversial writings, the secular image of our much loved city was at stake. So obviously, she being transported to Delhi to maintain peace and harmony in the city was a much better idea. Now also the Islamic fundamentalists and jehadis seem to be waiting in Bangladesh to lynch her. Atleast India had the guts to give her shelter so long!
1 Stars
Mayuri Majumdar
Kolkata, India
I, an inhabitant of Kolkata must admit, that people and activists in Kolkata are busy fighting for Nandigram and etc. These are basically political issues which would bring the actvists in limelight. Fighting for justice is not anyone’s forte anymore.
1 Stars
Desh
Shimla, India
Being secular doesn’t mean you keep on allowing such religious blasphemy. I am not supporting the Indian Govt.’ decision, but she seriously needs to vacate India and should find solace in any other country. Be it vote politics or public verdict, abuses against any religion should not be tolerated.
1 Stars
@DESH
Mate, i thought secularism meant tolerance and giving people the right to express themselves even if you feel contrary to what they do. And you always have the freedom to give a damn to what they say or even refute them. But you just can’t tell ’em to not express what they feel. This is what the Freedom of Expression and Thought is all about. And i personally feel, we are fortunate enough to be in India, and also being to be able to exercise this fundamental right of ours. Look at what happened in Pakistan when blogs against the government were taken down were taken down and the press brutally put down. The Indian government, not letting Taslima live in India, is indirectly tantamount to curbing freedom of expression!!!
1 Stars
Prasad
Howrah, India
As an ashamed India, all I can say that we are sorry to watching you leaving India. We just love you writings and we will be waiting for your return to Kolkata soon. Politicians are forcing you to leave but our affection would force you to come India once again.
1 Stars
Desh
Shimla, India
Sure, what Jaya says is right but my friend, while expressing, public sentiments should be taken care of. What I mean to say is if anyone goes on to hurt the religious beliefs, then the people concerned or affected therefrom should decide themselves what the next course of action should be? Sorry to say, but the connection between Taslima and the excerpt from Pakistan is beyond my thinking capacity.
1 Stars
@DESH
I meant the Indian Government is almost behaving like Pakistan by denying Taslima a place here, in this country. By the line ”behaving like Pakistan”, i meant the times in the recent past when Pakistan’s president Pervez Musharraf didn’t let bloggers and the Pakistani media express themselves and imposed heavy curbs on them. i’l be very glad if i have clarified myself DeshBhai. LoL
1 Stars
Ekta
Jaipur, India
A website has published her letter to a news agency describing how bad she was feeling during her stay in Delhi. - "It has been nearly eight months that I have been living under virtual house arrest, in a prison without any facilities. I have been asked continuously by the government to leave this country. Naturally, this has upset me a great deal as I left Europe to relocate to India; to make India my permanent home. I settled in Kolkata where I was living peacefully in a Bengali milieu. I was very active helping oppressed women and writing feminist and humanist literature. Just because a few Muslim fundamentalists objected to my being in this country, I was first imprisoned in Kolkata and then moved to Delhi. In order for the politicians to secure their Muslim vote bank, I had to be locked up and, as a consequence, my health was irreparably destroyed." - This was the treatment she was receiving under the nose of Pranab Mukherjee.
1 Stars
Desh
Shimla, India
@ Jayprashanth, Mayuri Majumdar and Blah blah... and all those who are in love with Taslima, please follow the comment here:

See, here case is not of giving shelter and later denying, rather the question is why should we give shelter to her??? Why again?? I may sound a bit freak but being an Indian I strictly believe that we could not afford to give shelter every person here. this is the sheer idiotic Indian politics that runs amuck that I always failed to understand, as I cited above.

Secondly, if we are that much bothered about Taslima’s refuge then why we didn’t hide Saddam here or Osama bin laden for that matter? since the case of saddam is late now but option for laden is still open? LOLLLLLLLLZZZZZZZZ
1 Stars
Prabhunarayan
Pondicherry, India
It is a disgrace for India that she had to leave our country because of the communal vote bank politics played by most communal parties in India - Indian National Congress and the communist parties of India like CPM, CPI, Forward Bloc, RSP etc.

It is highly embarrassing for Indian citizens like me to see such a despicable act committed by current Indian ruling party politicians and its strange bedfellows - the communists.
1 Stars
@Desh
Then why don’t you ask why India harbours the Dalai Lama? You might as well pose such questions.
I have an answer straight from an eighth standard civics textbook, Because India is a Secular country.
And i would like to ask you a question, how can you even compare Osama Bin Laden and Saddam Hussain to Taslima Nasreen. If you can answer that, we can further this debate!!!LoL
1 Stars
Chintan
Ambala, India
desh raj -

i agree india cannot afford to give shelter to more people. in fact, one more person taking shelter in india would be like the proverbial last straw that breaks the camel's back.

now how would explain the millions of bangladeshi infiltrators who are systematically regularized as indian citizens right along the india-bangladesh border in west bengal? because they form a sizable vote bank for the communists. the congress did exactly the same in the border areas of assam. situation is such now that indians in those areas have become minorities to those illegal immigrants who now claim to be indian citizens with proper documentation.

don't comment on something like an expert on a subject that you don't know much about.
1 Stars
@chintan
Bang on!!! well said mate, even that is an issue. When India can harbour thousands of Bangladeshi refugees, why can’t we, i mean the Indian government, let a prominent writer who dares to speak her mind, live here in our country???
1 Stars
Desh
Shimla, India
Jayprashanth

First of all thanks for citing Dalai Lama and again the question remains why should we shelter, but here comes again my friend Jay with his argument of secularism. But my friend why don’t you understand that we can not propagate secularism for all the asylum seekers. though I firmly believe in secularism for all irrespective of religion or caste but we can’t judge different ppl with the different sticks. IF we’ll be having that much high feeling of philanthropy, egalitarianism, then we need thousands of charity institutes and refugee camps and I hope you won’t mind to contribute with both hands. What say?????lolzzzzzzzzz.

And the case you cited, on the basis of that Osama Bin Laden and late Saddam deserve the same on secular grounds, if being secular then why India banished M. F Hussain???? doesn’t he deserve the freedom of expression???
1 Stars
@Desh
Yeah, i agree i forgot to add M.F Hussain DeshBhai. So what are you trying to say, We have to keep repeating the mistake we have been making. Torturing Taslima Nasreen by house arresting her when she needed medical attention and now banishing her is wrong and i firmly stand by what i said before. Do you think Osama did us all a favour by bombing the WTC and did Saddam not kill millions of his own country people in Iraq? What did Taslima do for you to compare her with the aforementioned sadistic creatures?
She just expressed her thoughts on Islam which might have hurt other people, but that doesn’t mean she can be equated to Osama and Saddam. Where is the right to expression? If that was missing, we couldn’t be here sitting and debating this issue,.,.And talking about charity, i really wouldn’t mind sparing a few bucks for the needy, which in this case would be the Bangladeshi refugees. And i recollect hearing stories about Indian students having collected money for Bangladeshi Independence by polishing shoes,.,so what does all this imply..,We are a bunch of secular people and our government has let us down by not giving Taslima Nasreen and M.F Hussain their creative space and this has left an indelible black mark on our claim of being a secular nation.
1 Stars
By the way, we can certainly accomodate a few asylum seekers in India. And we desperately need to see the bigger picture. Not letting Taslima Nasreen stay in India has deep political and fundamental undertones. Firstly, votebank politics and secondly, fundamentalist forces. We cannot let our country be dominated by fundamentalist forces who dictate terms to suit their vested interest and make us look like fools to the entire world. And propagating such intolerance will just lead india to become more fragmented and polarised. We are one nation where people speaking hundreds of languages and following various religions co-exist peacefully tolerating each other. Incidents like these will only cause to disrupt this wonderful harmony. I think i’ve made my point very clear!!!
2 Stars
Rudolf irokoproductions.com
New York, United States
I am currently reading young female writers from Asia. I am marvelled by their talent. I hate to read that any of them is not free to write. It is not just the loss of any particular country. It is my loss, too.
1 Stars
G emeraldsandash.blogs..
Canberra, Australia
@Rudolf

I agree. It is the world’s loss.
1 Stars
Desh
Shimla, India
@chintan, In a way or the other, the comments are attesting what I m trying to say. It’s not a matter of Bangla refugees or some others. No doubt, Indian Govt. and Pranab Mukherjee has done the right thing but a bit later. On some ground or other, all radicals have some point to prove, though we may or may not agree to their standpoint. Taslima is, certainly, not a radical but her Lajja, seriously, brought her so much of criticism that to allow her to stay here in India definitely will send a message that you can express whatever you like and if anything unfavorable happens, we are here to accept your woes and worries. I m not trying to be an expert on anything; what I perceive I m penning it down. Lol.
1 Stars
Taslima wrote rubbish as far as the literary merit of her works is concerned. Content is another issue. She was thrown out of her own nation and she was a leech here. Instead of being grateful,she has at last shown her true colors in condemning us. I think she had issues to settle abroad before moving there. Good riddance.
Add your Comment